
One thing that surprised me greatly when I began to read m/m romance was how much I loved cowboy stories. This was surprising because before then I hadn't been too fussed about cowboy romance. I'd read a couple of Harlequin cowboy books and although they were pretty well written the heroes just didn't get my blood pumping the way, say, a Regency hero did. I also can't stand film Westerns. Hub had to drag me kicking and screaming to see Unforgiven and had to endure the punishment of sitting through all 6 hours of the BBC Pride and Prejudice adaptation as penance (not that it was penance because he admitted that he'd liked it after he'd watched it).
Anyway, I digress.
So what is it then about cowboy m/m which sends my heart a flutter as well as other parts of my anatomy? Good grief! It must be time for a list. I haven't done one of these in months!
1. It's just so different to the life that I know
Texas might as well be on another planet, it's so different to the UK. I may live in sheep farming country here in North Leeds, but it's nothing like the hot, dusty plains of a desert ranch. Sometimes I like reading about places that are different and cowboy books provide the perfect setting for that.
2. Cowboys find it difficult to talk about their feelings
Unless you're reading JL Langley who has the most eloquent cowboys imaginable, most cowboys don't talk much - about anything really, but mostly not about their feelings. They tend to bottle it up, meaning that all that pent up emotion manifests itself in other, more physical ways. It also means that with a cowboy book I'm pretty much guaranteed not to have to wade through pages of soppy dialogue. Yee haw!
3. They ride horses
This was one of my favourite bits about Regency romance too: Men on horseback. I don't ride horses. In fact I've only been on a horse once in my life when I went on one of the 15 minutes fun rides as a child. However, there's just something about a man who stands tall on a horse, that mastery of man and beast that I find irresistible in a hero.
4. They work with their hands but often run their own businesses too
It's such a delightful mix of a man who has intelligence enough to make a successful venture of running a ranch yet isn't afraid to get down and dirty out on the range when necessary. It's just so...so...manly that I can't resist.
5. They often have to live in a homophobic atmosphere
Much of the conflict in m/m cowboy books arises as a result of the homophobia prevalent in small town US. This can lead to internal conflict - I hate myself for fancying other men, or external - if anyone finds out, I'm dead meat. If it's done well, then this conflict usually leads to a satisfying plot. If it's done badly - usually when the whole town suddenly becomes 'gay OK' after centuries of homophobia - then I'll end up rolling my eyes and wondering which planet I've suddenly been transported to.
6. Cowboy hats
There's something about a man in a hat that just does it for me. The way that they use it to hide their eyes (and their emotions) from people, tip their hat in politeness and lose their hats in the throes of passion is just delicious. I think men should go back to wearing hats, I really do. Mind you the bowler hat just doesn't have the same sexiness as a Stetson!
So there you have it, six reasons why I love cowboys books. How about you? Do you love a good cowboy m/m or do they just not have the same appeal?








Jen, some of the points you describe making you love cowboys we share, others not.
ReplyDeleteI have nothing with horses. Imo they smell and not in a good way.
Also I am not fond of big empty spaces. We don´t have them here.
I do like the way how they cope with small town US/texas and their feelings.
Cowboys are one of those archetypes that just DO IT for me. Sorry.
ReplyDeleteMaybe because in CT we don't really have cowboys. They are exotic and smell like leather and sweat and stetson and tobacco.
On second thought......
I'm kind of meh on cowboys. Some I love, some I tolerate. As for your reasons:
ReplyDelete#1 - Growing up in Western Canada (while its no Texas) has PLENTY of wide open spaces. Not such a novelty.
#2 - I grew up in farming communities and while they may not all be "cowboys" they share a lot of commonalities, they just ride ATV's rather than horses. They can be as annoying as hell.
#3 - Okay, I do love me some horses. I can ride for pleasure but have no real skill unlike my daughter who takes lessons.
#4 - I grew up on a farm where I take that for granted. All the men I knew mostly had their own business (farm) and got down and dirty. Not a novelty again.
#5 - This is where some of the stories lose it for me. I get really frustrated with the "I will get my ass kicked" stories because intolerance makes me berserk. Its hard to enjoy hot cowboy smexin' when you are pissed off at everyone else in the book.
#6 - Two words "hat head" LOL Hats don't do it for me although they can look dashing. So I guess I'm on the fence. LOL
So it doesn't sound like I love cowboy stories and cowboy historicals I'm really not into but I'm not anti-cowboy either. I guess they fall into the lawyer/accountant/artist thing, just another career with its own quirks.
Hi Ingrid
ReplyDeleteI don't know how much horses smell 'cos I've never really got up close and personal with one, so I suppose that aspect doesn't really bother me.
LBea: A woman after my own heart. I love that they're all alpha and stuff. Mind you, I bet if I met one in RL I'd want to kill him after 10 minutes!
Tam: My, what a comprehensive answer :)
I see your point. If you've already had plenty of experience with those types of men then I don't expect you would be bothered about reading about them.
Hat head LMAO!
I saw the smell of horses described as being comforting . Just yuck!
ReplyDeleteThe reason I still have not bought Sutcliff cove is that is all about learning to ride a horse (next to falling in love of course). It is just not my thing.
Hat heads exists Jen. Some people look better when they put on a hat and others don't no matter what shape or colour.
Ingrid: I haven't read Sutcliff Cove either. Not because of the plot but rather that I just haven't got around to reading it yet.
ReplyDeleteI'm one of those people who looks dreadful in a hat. I've always admired those who can pull off the hat look :).
I'm with you on the novelty factor - we don't get many cowboys in London either, except the ones trying to sell me mobile phone contracts.
ReplyDeleteHorses do nothing for me and I hyperventilate if I see too much green at once - but yes, I think those situations are just one big concentration of MAN-ness, a perfect breeding ground (no pun intended) for some m/m tension. :)
I only read them now and again because they can feel *too* alien. I loved Victor Banis' Longhorns.
I don't look dreadful with a hat *g* but I don't wear them a lot.
ReplyDeleteI hyperventilate if I see too much green at once Lol Clare. You have not grown up on the country side I suppose??
*hehe*
ReplyDeleteI'm a city gal, I confess! I was born by the sea, on the south coast, but even then we were in the city. I mean, you just have to travel so much further for a good pair of shoes, don't you?! LMAO
(this is just to annoy Hubby who WAS brought up in the country and mourns having to follow me to the grimy depths of London :))
Poor hubby!
ReplyDeleteI grew up on the country side as well. More space there. Although how much open space is there in NL?
The city I live in now, has some good shoe shops!
Clare: I must read Longhorns. It's on my tbb list (which is currently a mile long).
ReplyDeleteYou won't like it where I live. You can see the rolling hills of Wharfedale and Ilkley moor from my house! Then again we do have Harvey Nics only a 15 min train journey away for all shoe shopping requirements!
I do like the smell of horses. Hanging around during my daughter's riding lessons. But she's worse. She prefers to shower the morning after lessons so she can sleep with the smell of horses on her all night. She better be finding herself a country boy I guess. LOL
ReplyDeleteYour first para could be a description of my own feelings about reading westerns. Where we differ is in that I love me a good cowboy movie. :)
ReplyDeleteGrowing up in the country there's no novelty factor for me either, but there is something so deliciously manly about the cowboy archetype. I think for me is that they appear so very comfortable and capable in their own skin and that is so very attractive... at least for me it is.
Re: horses - I'm not a huge fan, but, Good God, give me a pic of a cowboy sitting atop a horse and I'm a goner. LOL.
The only cowboys who've tripped my trigger have been Jack and Ennis (read, Jake and Heath) from BbM.
ReplyDeleteYes, I'm that shallow. ;-)
Seriously, I think what has turned me off more than anything are certain authors' attempts to write in dialect. Unless one is a master at that, it can grate on my nerves like Roseanne Barr singing "The Star-Spangled Banner." And I mean in no time flat.
I love cowboy stories. It's the jeans. :)
ReplyDeleteI have yet to read a book where an american did not have a jeans.
ReplyDeleteOne does not need to be a cowboy to own one.
Me likes the cowboys. It's the long coats and the swagger.
ReplyDeleteKris
ReplyDeleteI think for me is that they appear so very comfortable and capable in their own skin and that is so very attractive
That's a great way of putting it, and very true. You don't often find nervous, unsure cowboys.
KZ: I don't mind dialect as long as it's done well and is kept up throughout the story in both internal and external dialogue. A good dialect will add to characterisation.
Sarah: Yeah, especially when they fit so nicely round a well shaped arse. :)
Ingrid: True. Jeans are popular here too. Cowboy jeans are often well worn in all the right places ;).
Sean: Oh yes, the swagger, and the arrogance, and the tight jeans (did I already mention that?).
Not that I'm obsessed or anything.
http://headlines.nos.nl/forum.php/list_messages/16619
ReplyDeleteThis one is lacking his jeans..
Ingrid: When I was looking for a picture to go with this post I Googled 'Naked Cowboy' which, as you might expect, given that I'd switched off safe-search, gave me some very...er...interesting pictures. However, there were loads and loads of pictures of this guy strolling round NY having his photo taken with members of the public!
ReplyDeleteI did not know him untill I saw him on the dutch newssite this afternoon.
ReplyDeleteI really love cowboy romance - both m/m and m/f. Got a thing for those men in chaps. :)
ReplyDeleteof course in RL?? Yeah, not so much. lol
Tracy: Now chaps don't really do a thing for me. I'm not really into the whole worn leather look. I much prefer denim. :)
ReplyDeleteI can't help remembering though when I was younger and at a rodeo. Those chaps covering the denim clad ass was just a sight to see, let me tell ya! lol Of course I was much younger and may not feel the same were I at a rodeo now! lol
ReplyDeleteAnd I love cowboy hats. :)